I ordered there a few times already. I think its great to have a place over there in the middle of nowhere - where your choices are either gas station hot dogs from the kangaroo or gas station hot dogs from the BP station. Pizza was good. My kids LOVED it. The staff were all friendly. I pray they work out- they need it over there. And all the complainers - give it some time... they are still rather new.
Ordered online at 6:30pm, got a reply saying pizza and Stromboli would be ready at 7:05. At 7:35 got worried that my husband had not returned. Pizza place is about 4 minutes or less from the house. Drove to Palm Coast Pizza and there was my husband sitting calmly WAITING for his order. I asked the guy at the counter what's up and he proclaimed that they were very busy and did just manage to put our order in. I said that was unacceptable and he stated that's the way it was, he further went on and said if I had called in they would have told me the order would have been longer than 35 minutes but as I chose to use online they had no way too let us know. Gee, I thought the reply had come from them!
Anyway I really didn't care to be eating lousy pizza at 8pm and that's what it was LOUSY. The Stromboli was decent but I will NEVER order anything there again. Even if the pizza was fair I would not order from there because of the way we were treated. Both workers behind the counter thought my tirade was funny. No way to run a business.
Today is the second time I've ordered from here,and both times I had it delivered. Both times I was very pleased with the food! Along with the people on the phone/ delivery guys, all very friendly and helpful. I will order from there again! :)
About two weeks ago a submitted a review praising this place as the best I have had in Palm Coast. My review was very premature. I had knee surgery so I asked my wife to pick me up two slices. Wow... what happened ? The slices were dry and very, very, salty. Could not believe the difference. Just plain awful... I mean the worst. Can not believe how bad . Only ate half one one slice, the other went to the trash, and so did this place. Won't ever go back... Next time I review a place I will go at least twice. Still can not understand how a restaurant can be fantastic one day and horrendous just two weeks later.
Food is less than mediocre. Cheap quality. Minimal flavor. The first time we ordered, we figured they'd just opened and had to work out the kinks. We gave them another chance and it was just as bad. The Greek salad is just a garden salad with a sprinkle of cheap feta and 2 olives thrown on top. The subs are dry with very poor quality bread. The gyros are decent, but nothing special. Maybe we'll wait a few months and hope they get it together and give them another try. But as for now, they won't get anymore of our money.
Forget about the atmosphere, but the Pizza here is the best I have had since I moved to Palm Coast from Chicago eighteen years ago. I was swept away by the flavor. Great ingredients, and the dough was to die for.
Do yourself a favor and try this place. It will knock your socks off. They sell Pizza by the slice, so get two slices and enjoy, and judge for yourself. The negative review was probably when they first opened up. They've been at this location less than a month so you be the judge.
02/12/2016 ordered take out. Caesar salad, I believe it was made a couple of days in advance because the lettuce was yellow and wilted the and the tomatoes had black spots and soggy and the flavor just wasn't there. I put it in the garbage! Also ordered a chicken roll that was mostly dough. Chicken fingers also ordered, but were greasy. I enjoy good food and the food that I received was below the standards that I am accustomed too. I do not recommend this New York Style restaurant..
Kind of a strange location on the side of a gas station but they seem to of made the most of it. The young guy inside was very friendly and the place was clean and comfortable. They have pizza by the slice and gyros plus the usual pies and calzones. Our pie wasn't too bad but nothing better than most of the other pizza in Palm Coast. But it's nice to have a local neighborhood pizza joint and it's definitely better than the chain garbage.